Friday, June 4, 2010

Concert Review: Neil Young at The Ryman in Nashville

Now that you made yourself love me
Do you think I can change it in a day?
How can I place you above me?
Am I lying to you when I say
That I believe in you
I believe in you.
--Neil Young, "I Believe In You"

In March of 2005, Neil Young got the news that no one wants to hear: he had a brain aneurysm. Of course, what did he do between diagnosis and surgery? He wrote and recorded Prairie Wind. And then, Jonathan Demme made a movie, Heart of Gold, centered around the new songs, at The Ryman in Nashville, where his 2010 Twisted Road Solo Tour just passed through for two shows.

But what I tend to forget is that two days after his aneurysm surgery, Neil Young went on a walk outside his hotel. He only made it half a block.

His femoral artery, where the surgeons entered his body to access his brain, burst on the street. There was blood in his shoe. He barely made it back to the hotel. Neil Young was unconscious, but an emergency crew responded and revived him.

Somehow, revival and The Ryman go hand in hand with Neil Young and his music. On his current tour, Young is performing solo, bringing out a number of hits along with a wealth of new material. It isn't a solo acoustic jaunt; it's thunderous at times, so much that when Young plugged in and delivered "Down By the River" on Wednesday evening, you could feel the vibrations in The Ryman's pews (yes, you sit in pews at The Ryman).

If there's anything that needs to be said about this tour, it's that Young is feeling something serious and close to home in his heart. His first three songs, "My My, Hey Hey," "Tell Me Why," and "Helpless," were performed beautifully and acoustically, with Young sitting down, comfortable, singing so sweet that almost everyone sang along: "Helpless, Helpless, Helpless"...we sang with him. It was a special moment for me since that's the only song I can (sort of) play on guitar. And finally, I was watching him play it, at one of the best venues I've ever visited. I'll be honest: I held back tears.

Neil Young does this to you in a solo setting. For me, and I've seen him 19 times now, it's the best way to see him perform. The songs are stripped down, with every word hitting you clearly like the first time you sang along to "Old Man" in your car with a friend, or in your living room when no one else was around. It's why I will probably try to catch Young again on this tour--he hasn't done a solo tour in the U.S. since 1999. It's a special landscape for a man and his art.

And luckily, Young is still creating his art. There were plenty of new songs featured at The Ryman, and while, lyrically, they're all pretty direct, they do come from a special place. One of the best ones, "You Never Call," a song presumably about Young's friend, the late L.A. Johnson, included lighthearted lines like "You're in heaven with nothing to do/ The ultimate vacation with no back pain." Another new one, "Love and War," was just as strong.

"I sang for justice and I hit a bad chord, but I still try to sing about love and war," Young sang.

Like I mentioned earlier, it seems something special has hit Young. Even the older songs he chose to perform, like "Cortez the Killer," "Ohio," and "Cinnamon Girl," seemed new and fresh. Young gave every song, old or new, an eerie sense of space, a new sense of freedom that didn't once belong. A new twisted road.

If you do get to see Young on this tour, go in with a clear mind. Go in with a sense that you're going to hear your favorite songs performed for you for the first time. Go in wanting to hang on every word, every note.

Go in realizing that we're lucky Neil Young is still alive, still creating, and not resting on his laurels.

When the show was over, I thought of my first Neil Young show in St. Louis at The Fox Theatre. I went with my sister, Joy, and we sat in the second row in the orchestra pit. I remember watching Young walk out on stage that night. My sister nudged me and whispered, "There he is!" I'll always remember that moment--Neil Young, alone, sauntering out with a wry smile, waving his hand, and then blowing us away with a few acoustic guitars, a banjo, various harmonicas, an upright piano, a grand piano, and a vintage organ.

I met Neil Young that night. He even took a picture with me. All I really told him was "thank you."

Well, Neil, thanks again.

Setlist, courtesy of Sugar Mountain:
1. My My, Hey Hey (Out Of The Blue)
2. Tell Me Why
3. Helpless
4. You Never Call
5. Peaceful Valley
6. Love And War
7. Down By The River
8. Hitchhiker
9. Ohio
10. Sign Of Love
11. Leia
12. After The Gold Rush
13. I Believe In You
14. Rumblin'
15. Cortez The Killer
16. Cinnamon Girl
17. Old Man
18. Walk With Me


  1. Wow that's a great read. I agree... I love his solo shows as well. Same as Springsteen. When you hear the songs stripped down, it just draws you in more.

    You've seen him 19 times! WOW! That's awesome!

    The Ryman sounds SO good... love that venue!

  2. My husband and I were there too; thank you for capturing that special night so beautifully.

  3. I flew in from NC for this show, and I too have seen him some 15 or 16 times, with & without backing bands. This was, and will be, one of the most memorable. The Ryman pews and columns were indeed vibrating on his electric classics, and all I could think was: How is he performing these songs so well . . . without Crazy Horse?? Well, I guess it's because he is, quite simply, a legend.

    If you get the chance to see this tour, do NOT pass it up!

  4. I first saw Neil in 1969 in SLC at the old Salt Palace. It was right after Woodstock and I went to see Santana. I can still see Neil walk out in his white ruffled shirt. I could not take my eye of him then and 30+ shows later I am still just as rewarded. I had to hear him in the Ryman. We flew in from SLC. I am a teacher and money is tight, but what is the price of mental health? I got to see both shows. I talked with an old usher that told me all about Ben and taking pitchers with him and Neil. I love hearing stories like that!Neil keeps me sane and lets me be nuts. Neil keeps me on the road and lets me jump the ditch. I plan on driving to Reno, Nev. to see him again. Hell, I saw Greendale 5 times and went to the Hard rock in Vegas to see it there, but they could not fit it on stage. As I was peeking through the crack in the doors before the show during the sound check, Zeke came to the door and told me I would see a special Crazy Horse show, and did I ever! That's what Neil does, delight with upredictability. I know we are not immortal. I know we are tied somehow on our journey. I am glad I am traveling when and where I can with Neil.

  5. Went to the shows in Knoxville and Nashville. Song list pretty much the same for both shows. He stil has the the pipes.